5 Symptoms of a Bad Coil Spring in Your Suspension (And Replacement Cost)

Coil springs are the major component of modern suspension systems that keep your vehicle “suspended” off the ground. These springs absorb impact from bumps in the road by compressing and expanding.

How Do Coil Spring Suspensions Work?

how hydraulic suspension system works

The compression and rebound of the coil spring, coupled with the damping applied by the shock absorbers, work to keep each tire in contact with the road at all times. Coil springs are also a key factor in determining the ride height of your vehicle.

There are four coil springs to support the weight of your entire vehicle, which means each of these springs must be incredibly strong. Each spring is designed from the factory with a specific spring rate that maximizes comfort and performance for your particular vehicle.

Springs and shocks are the two main components that determine how your vehicle reacts to bumps. Some shocks are mounted inside the coil spring. This is called a coil-over shock absorber suspension setup, or “coilover” for short.

Many vehicles come with coilover suspension from the factory, but there are a plethora of aftermarket options available that allow you to lower your ride height or alter spring rates for better cornering performance.

The upper part of the coil spring is positioned below the spring perch (sometimes called a top hat in coilover suspensions) while the bottom part of the spring is positioned on the lower control arm. As you may know, the lower control arm assists in keeping the wheels securely held in place.

Since the spring is above the lower control arm, it absorbs all the shock from down below. That way, the people inside the cabin above the coil spring can remain comfortable as they drive over obstacles on the road.

Top 5 Bad Coil Spring Symptoms

If you have a bad coil spring in your car, there are definitely going to be some noticeable symptoms that you will experience. Once you recognize them for what they are, you should do something about them immediately.

Below are five of the most common signs you have a faulty coil spring.

1) Sagging Corner

uneven suspension

If you have a bad coil spring, that corner of the vehicle might sag more or appear lower than the other corners. This will easily be noticeable simply by looking at it from the outside.

But when you are driving the vehicle, you will have less stability from this sagging too. This problem will cause other symptoms to get worse, such as excessive tire wear and tear.

2) Bounciness


Coil springs are supposed to keep the vehicle from shaking and bouncing up and down as it goes down the road. But if you have bad coil springs in your vehicle, then they won’t be able to prevent this bounciness.

This means that you will experience a lot of bouncing and shaking as you drive, especially if you travel over rough terrain or roads with many potholes. This will likely make the vehicle very difficult to control. 

Note that a bad shock may exhibit similar symptoms. Typically bad shocks are unable to absorb the rebound of the spring, so your car feels more like a trampoline when you hit a big bump.

See Also:  10 Best Shock Absorber Brands

3) Uneven Wear on Tires

worn tire treads

Coil springs are supposed to keep the wheels and tires in contact with the road at all times. This allows the tires to receive an equal amount of wear and tear as they’re moving on the road.

If you have bad coil springs, your tires may even leave the road at times, just under regular driving conditions. Once that happens, the tire treads will wear prematurely and unevenly (ie: inner or outer tire wear) causing drivability issues on the road. You will also need to replace tires much quicker than normal even if tire rotation is done.

4) Rattling or Clunking

strange noise

In addition to the shaking that you will experience from bad coil springs, there will be an annoying clunking or rattling noise coming from the suspension system too. This rattling noise will increase in volume as you accelerate the vehicle more and drive over rough roads.

Do not just ignore this rattling noise because it is an early warning sign that you need to get your coil spring replaced.

5) Warning Light

traction control light on

Most newer vehicles have warning lights for the traction control system of the vehicle. There are sensors built into the suspension which keep track of the vehicle’s stability.

Whenever the sensors detect any unusual behavior, it will cause the warning light to illuminate on the dashboard. Take this as a warning sign that there’s a problem with your suspension, possibly your coil springs.

You might not realize the exact problem at the time, but you will know soon enough if you experience the other symptoms too.

How Long Do Coil Springs Last?

coil spring replacement cost

Since coil springs are thick, round pieces of steel, they typically last the entire life of the vehicle. The main exception to the rule is on cars with significant corrosion.

You may experience high levels of corrosion on your vehicle if you live in the Salt Belt in the United States, for instance. If your roads are salted, expect the life of all external components to be drastically reduced. One way to mitigate this is with frequent undercarriage washing during the winter months when roads are salted.

If your vehicle’s suspension system has been modified by either cutting the springs or using spring clamps, the life of the coil spring may be reduced. Spring clamps put constant, uneven compression on the coil spring in a way it was not designed for.

Coil Spring Replacement Cost

We recommend Parts Geek for the best prices and selection.

Coil springs are inexpensive parts that typically cost around $70 to $150 for the part alone (multiply this by four if you are replacing all your coil springs). Labor cost ranges from $150 to $400, depending on the vehicle. Sometimes you can buy a pre-assembled coilover, which substantially cuts down on installation time.

Since it’s generally recommended to replace suspension components in pairs (left and right), the total cost will likely be higher if you are replacing components on both sides of the vehicle.

Can I Replace Coil Springs Myself?

spring compressor

While it is possible to replace coil springs yourself, you should really know what you’re getting into; this is a job that’s often best left to the professionals. Make sure you do plenty of research on your specific vehicle before you decide if attempting this job is right for you.

Even when your vehicle is lifted off the ground, coil springs are under a tremendous amount of force, which means they have a dangerous amount of potential energy stored. The larger your vehicle, the stronger the springs have to be. Many springs can only be replaced by using a spring compressor.

coil spring uncompressed
Look how much taller this spring is uncompressed. That spring was under a lot of pressure in the coilover.

Use extreme caution when using a spring compressor, as misuse could cause serious injury or even death. Only compress the spring as much as is necessary, and wear gloves and eye protection at a minimum.


5 thoughts on “5 Symptoms of a Bad Coil Spring in Your Suspension (And Replacement Cost)”

  1. I am replacing coils springs that dip too deep into the turns, although they seem fine otherwise. It was a used assembly from a junk yard my kid picked up to save money replacing only a spring seat on the existing set up that turned marvelously however a tad harsher when just travelling straight. I bought new springs and now to my horror I se the struts are leaking so I will go new struts, seats, mounts, etc., for all new.

    Of the 2 springs I ordered from Rock Auto, one had a few deep scratches in the metal beyond just the coating. I painted it to prevent rust as it was not that deep to effect performance but I worry about rusting fast.

    Another time time Rock Auto shipped tie rods in two different sized boxes but the parts were the same and they seem to have worked as far as I know so hopefully this scratch in the metal of the spring won’t be a big deal either. Maybe its a poorly inspected return which also begs the question why it was returned. Its a hit or miss with these guys.

    • Agreed that it can be very hit or miss with Rock Auto, but they have a decent return policy if you have an issue.

      Some of the cheaper options on their site are aftermarket or remanufactured parts, which is OK if you know what you’re getting yourself into. Not all of these parts will fit correctly with OEM brackets or hardware. They may have damage or minor defects, as you’ve seen in your case.

      Brake caliper dragging on your daily? No worries, you might just need a cheap rebuilt caliper and don’t care so much about looks. Rock Auto is good for this. The same is true for springs and shocks.

      Rock Auto also has different tiers of parts. They send you higher quality parts when you pay for the more expensive options on their site.

  2. 2010 VW Jetta sports wagon, TDI was equipped with stock rear springs. is there an after-market spring with more spring to it? I don’t want to lower the rear end, but to raise it so it drives well with people in the back seat and luggage behind them.

    Springs probably were ok for sedans but the wagon is just heavier with all that glass and steel above the rear axle.


Leave a Comment